best youth catchers mitt

Best Youth Catchers Mitt In 2024 (See Our Top 5)

Table of Contents

best youth catchers mitt

Finding the right best youth catchers mitt for 2023 can make a big difference for a young catcher. This guide is here to help you look at the available choices. In this article, we list our top five picks for the best youth catchers gloves, and we offer helpful tips for picking the one that’s best for your young player.

Top 5 Best Catcher’s Mitts

Before you make a purchase, check out our rundown of the best youth baseball catcher mitts available in the market.

1. Wilson A2000 Baseball Glove Series

Our Pick
Wilson A2000 Baseball Catcher's Mitt
  • Flat Finger Binding for better control
  • Pro Stock Leather for durability and feel
  • DriLex Wrist Lining keeps hand dry
  • Bold Logos add style and identity
  • Thinner toe pad for easier framing
  • Deep pocket for catching pitches in the dirt
  • Cool color schemes
  • Expensive
  • Can run small
  • Longer break-in time
Buy Now
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
04/23/2024 12:59 am GMT

The Wilson A2000 Catcher’s Mitt is considered the top youth level catcher’s mitt on the market for many reasons. Its design is perfect for catchers, with a thinner toe pad and deeper pocket that make framing and picking pitches out of the dirt much easier. The mitt’s Pro Stock Leather, known for its rugged durability, withstands the demands of a long season effectively.

Additionally, the DriLex Wrist Lining keeps the hand dry and comfortable during extended play. The Flat Finger Binding feature gives players who prefer to play with a finger outside the glove greater comfort and control.

The blonde, classic black and white pro stock leather combination gives the mitt a classic and professional look. Additionally, the half-moon web design provides flexibility and control when catching pitches.

With its superior design and construction, the Wilson A2000 Catcher’s Mitt is a reliable choice for any youth catcher looking for a high-quality mitt that can keep up with their game.

2. All Star Pro-Elite CM3000 32″

Runner Up
All Star Pro-Elite CM3000 32"
  • Premium-grade Japanese steerhide leather
  • Stiffer black leather backing for support
  • Adjustable wrist closure
  • Index finger hood for added protection
  • Extended pocket with profiled toe
  • Great for scooping
  • Price
  • Can have a longer break-in period
  • Might not be suitable for under 12U
Buy Now
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
04/23/2024 04:06 am GMT

The All-Star Pro Elite is one of our top tier choices for the best youth catcher’s mitts on the market. Firstly, it is made from exclusive, premium-grade Japanese tanned steer hide leather. This type of leather allows for a fast break-in and extended life. This mitt has a comfortable feel and will last a long time, even with regular use.

The soft tan leather pocket of the All-Star Pro Elite Youth Catchers Mitt allows for a great feel and gives the ball that extra pop that pitchers love to hear. Furthermore, the black leather backing is stiffer, which gives the mitt the right amount of support and increases its life. The mitt is also designed with an extended pocket and a profiled toe, which makes scooping easier.

The adjustable wrist closure ensures a secure fit, and the index finger hood on the mitt’s backing protects the index finger if the catcher decides to wear it outside of the mitt. The glove offers wrist protection as well as superior padding which helps in reducing sting.

As soon as you put it on, the first thing you will notice is how incredibly comfortable the pre-oiled full-grain leather is and how it’s surprisingly light for a catcher’s mitt. This glove is of all-star quality in every way imaginable.

3. Rawlings Heart Of The Hide Catchers Mitt

3rd Place
Rawlings Heart Of The Hide Catchers Mitt - 33"
  • Quality construction and materials
  • Great padding / Padded thumb sleeve
  • Holds shape well
  • Very comfortable
  • Expensive
  • Long break-in time
Buy Now
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
04/25/2024 05:05 am GMT

The Heart of the Hide Catchers Mitt is a standout choice for any young catcher looking for the best gear. This mitt’s key features include pro-level quality and a one-piece closed web for enhanced control and performance behind the plate. The ContoUR series provides a pattern tailored to smaller hands, ensuring the perfect fit. Lowered finger stalls also promote better contact with the back of the glove, giving players more control when fielding.

One of the best features of this mitt is its adjustable wrist opening. This allows players to create a custom, secure fit and improve their glove control. Another great feature of the catcher’s mitt is its deep pocket design. The design of the mitt enables it to securely hold onto the ball, minimizing the chance of it popping out during a play.

The manufacturers crafted this mitt with performance, durability, and comfort in mind, using ultra-premium steer-hide leather. The internal padding ensures the perfect pocket, while the deer tanned cowhide palm lining, thermoformed wrist liner, and padded thumb sleeve provide added comfort.

The Rawlings HOH Catcher’s Mitt is available in a 33-inch size. This mitt size works well for players who are looking for a slightly larger mitt to help them field balls more effectively. The mitt is also relatively lightweight, which helps to reduce hand fatigue during long games or practices.

4. Mizuno Prospect GXC Youth Catchers Mitt

Best Affordable Option
Mizuno Prospect Youth Catcher's Mitt 31.5 in
  • Great entry level glove
  • Affordable
  • Quality materials
  • Power close design
  • Palm padding can cause balls to bounce out
  • May not be suitable for players above 10U
Buy Now
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
04/24/2024 01:10 am GMT

Mizuno designed this mitt specifically for younger players, creating a smaller size and lightweight construction. It also features a comfortable wrist strap and soft palm liner for added comfort.

One of the standout features of the Mizuno Catchers Mitt is its Power Closing technology. This technology uses a unique pattern of stitching to create a closed web design that helps Little Leaguers catch the ball. The webbing is also flexible enough to allow the player to quickly transfer the ball from the mitt to their hand.

Another cool feature of the Mizuno is its comfortable wrist strap which helps secure the mitt on the player’s hand. The strap is adjustable, so players to customize the fit.

This makes it an excellent choice for catchers who are still developing their skills and may not require a larger mitt yet. It’s relatively lightweight, making it easier for younger players to handle and use effectively. With its Power Close technology, comfortable wrist strap, and lightweight design, this mitt can help young players improve their catching skills and gain confidence behind the plate.

5. Rawlings R9 Contour Baseball Catchers Mitt

The Rawlings R9 ContoUR Fit 32″ Baseball Catcher’s Mitt is a high-quality baseball glove designed specifically for youth players. It stands out with its game-ready design, featuring a soft, durable all-leather shell that allows players to use the glove immediately without the need for extensive breaking in. The glove incorporates pro patterns, and mirroring models used by MLB stars, which helps in enhancing the player’s feel and performance on the field.

The glove features a reinforced palm pad and a padded thumb loop for enhanced protection and comfort. These features are crucial for young players, as they provide the necessary safety and comfort during play. Additionally, the glove’s padded fingerback lining ensures a comfortable fit, which is essential during long games or practice sessions.

How Are Catcher’s Gloves Different?

When it comes to playing baseball, the catcher position is one of the most important on the field. Catchers need to be able to catch the ball, but also block the plate and stop wild pitches. Catcher gloves are different from those of other positions due to the wide range of skills that catchers must possess.

The absence of separate finger components in a mitt is the primary characteristic that differentiates it from a baseball glove. You can easily get a hold of the ball thanks to the mitt’s innovative design, which features a wider pocket than normal.

A catcher’s mitt offers extra protection and features a unique shape that helps the pitcher by providing a larger target to aim for. A larger target will hopefully assist them in throwing the ball more accurately.

best youth catchers mitt

What Size Catchers Mitt Do I Need?

Before we list our best youth catcher mitts, we need to make sure that you understand what size you need. Take a look at our chart below and use it as a general guideline. Some kids are bigger than others at certain ages but this should at least give you a good starting point.

Position Ages 5-8Ages 8-10Ages 11-13Ages 13+

Selecting The Best Youth Catchers Mitt

When it comes to catcher’s mitts, in particular, the requirements for a catcher’s equipment are more specific than those of any other position. Because there is such a wide selection of designs available, you must select the model that best fits your comfort level and the way you want to play.

When looking for the best option, there are a few things to keep in mind:

The grade of the leather

The mitt must require leather of the highest possible quality. The majority of catchers dislike it when their glove becomes too flimsy to be effective. Cheaper leather tends to lose its strength and shape over time, which makes it more difficult to catch baseballs.

Additionally, high-quality leather produces a loud pop when the ball is caught (pitchers love the sound). The quality of the leather determines how long it will remain stiff. Although breaking in quality leather takes more time, it will last far longer.

Break in time

Manufacturers shape some gloves and partially break them in at the factory before shipping them to customers, ensuring they are ready for use more quickly. This appeals to many players. Others favor the process of breaking in gloves on their own to make sure it molds to their hand.

Protection for the palms

Some players prefer extra palm protection in their gloves. However, others may find that they have a better feel for the ball without it.

What Are The Best Youth Catchers Mitt Brands?

Nokona – Nokona didn’t make the top 4 because of their high prices. Their baseball gloves are made in America and have been handcrafted in Nocona, Texas since 1934. Nokona crafts their gloves from top-quality steer hide and kangaroo leather, offering a variety of sizes and web patterns to suit different players’ needs.

Rawlings – Rawlings quality gloves are made from the finest leather and craftsmanship. They are perfect for the player who demands the best.

Wilson – Wilson makes great catcher’s mitts because they are made with high-quality materials and construction. The mitts are also designed to fit the hand of a catcher perfectly.

All-Star – All-Star makes a fantastic catcher’s mitt. Not as well known as Wilson or Rawlings, All-Stat mitts can definitely hang with the big boys. These mitts are designed from high-quality and durable leather.

Top Youth Catchers Mitt Options – Final Thoughts

For baseball catchers, choosing the right equipment is an important decision that can impact their performance and comfort on the field.

While the Wilson A2000 series stands out for its good quality and ease of use, the Rawlings Renegade offers the best value for those looking for an affordable price point. It’s important to consider factors like leather quality, appropriate size, and extra padding like the parashock palm pad for enhanced protection.

Remember, the most important things to consider are the player’s comfort, the mitt’s durability, and how it complements their style of play. Whether you’re looking for a leather mitt for its durability or a synthetic material mitt for its affordability, there’s a perfect catcher’s mitt out there for every young player.

Chris F.

Chris F.

Chris Forbes is the founder and editor of, a leading blog in the youth baseball space. As a lifelong baseball player, coach and fan, he decided to team up with his young son to offer advice and share their experiences with the sport they both love. Chris lives in the Boston area with his wife and three children.

Table of Contents

Shopping Cart